bet365
BetMGM
William Hill
Betfred
BetUK
LiveScoreBet
10Bet
Virgin Bet
Can St James’ Park tilt this semi-final Newcastle’s way before the Etihad return? Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.
To use the Live Streaming service you will need to be logged in and have a funded account or to have placed a bet in the last 24 hours. Geo location and live streaming rules apply.
▾
Celtic's 65% possession and 13+ shots per game will eventually break down the Talbot defense. Given Talbot have scored 2+ goals in four straight cup games and Celtic are weak at preventing chances, a high-scoring away win is the most logical outcome.
▾
Talbot have the form to snatch a goal against a Celtic side that lacks defensive solidity, but Celtic's 88.1% passing accuracy and wing-play dominance will result in multiple goals.
Readers’ Tip
Vote your pick — quick & anonymous
Terms & Conditions (tap to view)
Newcastle United vs Manchester City Predictions and Best Bets
Newcastle vs Man City — bet365 Market Snapshot
Informational layout showing implied probabilities from listed bet365 match prices.
Manchester City arrive as favorites, but Newcastle’s 13-game home unbeaten streak is reflected in a competitive price for the hosts.
With Haaland leading City’s attack and Newcastle averaging 2.67 goals in this competition, markets strongly anticipate a high-scoring game.
- Home Fortress Energy: Newcastle are unbeaten in 13 straight at St James’ Park with 10 wins and three draws, arriving on three wins and a draw in their last four.
- Cup Machine Mode: Newcastle have won nine straight in the EFL Cup and have scored 2+ goals in eight consecutive matches in the competition, averaging 2.67 goals.
- City’s Shot Volume & Ruthless Edge: Manchester City have 74 goals in 31 matches across all competitions, average 16.2 shots per game, and Erling Haaland has 20 league goals.
Offensive Output: Total Goals This Season
Both sides have shown a clinical edge across all competitions, with Manchester City hitting a massive season total while Newcastle maintain high cup scoring rates.
Averaging 2.67 goals per match in the EFL Cup specifically, hitting the net at least twice in eight consecutive competition fixtures.
Driven by high shot volume (16.2 per game), with primary threat Erling Haaland accounting for 20 league goals already.
Attacking Intent: Shots per Match
A comparison of how often both teams test the opposition, highlighting the persistent pressure expected at St James’ Park.
Their aggressive style at home has maintained a 13-game unbeaten run, forcing goalkeepers into regular action.
City’s high-possession approach (61.9%) consistently leads to high volume in the final third.
Two heavyweights, one place at Wembley on the line — and it starts at St James’ Park. Newcastle are defending their 2024-25 EFL Cup crown and they’ve played this competition like it matters: Bradford City swept aside 4-1, Tottenham beaten 2-0, Fulham edged 2-1 with a 92nd-minute winner from Lewis Miley.
Manchester City arrive chasing their first EFL Cup since 2020-21, carrying form that’s solid if not spotless: three wins and three draws in their last six, capped by a wild 10-1 FA Cup win over Exeter. It’s a first leg with real tension — Newcastle’s home roar versus City’s control — kicking off at 20:00.
Team News & Lineups
Newcastle United (Eddie Howe)
- Out: Sven Botman (knee surgery), Dan Burn (bruised ribs, out until 24.01.2026)
- Doubts: Malick Thiaw (unknown injury), Fabian Schär (unknown injury)
Probable XI:
Ramsdale; Miley, Thiaw, Botman, Hall; Tonali, Guimarães; Gordon, Woltemade, Barnes; Wissa
Implication:
- If Botman and Burn miss out as listed, Newcastle’s aerial and set-piece security takes a hit — not ideal when City bring Haaland and a wave of delivery.
- The upside? Newcastle still have quality and legs in midfield with Tonali and Guimarães, plus direct runners either side.
Manchester City (Pep Guardiola)
- Injuries/absences: None stated.
Probable XI:
Trafford; Nunes, Khusanov, Alleyne, O’Reilly; González; Cherki, Foden, Reijnders, Doku; Haaland
Implication:
- That front five screams chance creation: Cherki (7 assists), Doku (4 assists), Foden (7 goals), Reijnders (5 goals), finishing with Haaland (20 league goals).
- If City’s back line is unfamiliar, Newcastle’s fast breaks and set-piece punch become even more relevant.
The Tale of the Tape
| Metric | Newcastle | Man City |
|---|---|---|
| EFL Cup Goals | 8 (3 apps) | 7 (3 apps) |
| Shots per Game (All comps avg.) | 13.5 | 16.2 |
| Possession % (All comps avg.) | 53.2% | 61.9% |
| Pass % (All comps avg.) | 83.7% | 89.3% |
| Clean Sheets (All comps) | 10 | 13 |
| Goals For / Against (All comps) | 55 / 37 | 74 / 27 |
City bring the cleaner defensive record and the higher tempo in possession. Newcastle counter with cup momentum, a serious shot count of their own, and a home run that refuses to blink.
William Hill
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
BetMGM
Bet £10 Get £40 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
bet365
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Betfred
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
10bet
100% Up To £50 On First Deposit
Show Terms & Conditions
Tactical Battle: How the Match Plays Out
Newcastle’s route: pressure, punch, then swarm the box
Howe’s Newcastle are built to make nights like this ugly for the visitors. They like to control territory, hit crosses, and let shots fly — and with Woltemade drifting behind the striker and Barnes attacking the space, the danger comes in bursts.
The midfield duel is the engine room. Bruno Guimarães isn’t just a passer here — he’s Newcastle’s scorer too with 8 league goals and 3 assists, and he’ll try to drag City’s midfield into sprints rather than patterns. Add Tonali for balance, and Newcastle can turn a clearance into an attack in two passes.
Set pieces are a big lever. Newcastle are strong attacking and defending them, and with City strong defensively on dead balls too, it becomes a contest of first contact and second balls — who reacts, who panics, who switches off.
City’s route: suffocate, create angles, feed Haaland
Guardiola’s side will want long spells in Newcastle’s half. They control space with short passing, then slip through balls or isolate wide men — and they are very strong down the wings. Doku is the chaos button, Cherki supplies the final ball, and Foden floats into pockets to keep the attack moving.
The obvious finish is Haaland. He’s already on 20 league goals with 4 assists, and City’s shot volume (15.61 per game) means he won’t be starved for service.
There is one opening Newcastle will fancy: City can be weak at stopping opponents creating chances and weak protecting a lead. If Newcastle land first blood, the second phase of the match becomes frantic — and that’s where St James’ Park can drag this tie into its own mood.
Key Moments to Watch
- First-wave survival: City average higher possession (61%) and shots (15.61), so Newcastle’s first 20 minutes need calm heads and clean clearances.
- Wide battles: City attack down the wings with real intent; Newcastle’s wingers must track or it becomes cutbacks to Haaland all night.
- Midfield pressure valves: If Guimarães and Tonali play through pressure, Newcastle can flip the pitch fast — and City don’t love defending broken shapes.
What could go wrong?
Newcastle’s defensive absences could invite chaos at the back if City pin them in and keep recycling attacks. For City, over-commitment to control can open the door to one sharp transition — and Newcastle’s home record suggests they won’t need many invitations.
Best Bet for Newcastle vs Man City
Can the St James’ Park Atmosphere Halt City’s March to Wembley?
The Punter’s Cheat Sheet
| Factor | The Numbers | Betting Signal |
| Scoring | NEW 2.67/gm in Cup; MCI 74 goals total | Over 2.5 Goals |
| Attack | MCI 16.2 shots/gm; NEW 13.5 shots/gm | Both Teams to Score |
| Home Form | NEW 13-game unbeaten home run | Double Chance: NEW or Draw |
| Haaland | 20 league goals; 15.61 team shots/gm | Anytime Scorer |
[bt4y_article_veil]
Both Teams to Score & Over 2.5 Goals
Newcastle are currently a juggernaut in the EFL Cup, carrying a nine-game winning streak in the competition. They have scored at least two goals in eight consecutive cup fixtures, averaging 2.67 goals per match. This offensive consistency is paired with an incredible 13-game unbeaten run at St James’ Park, where they have secured 10 victories and three draws.
Manchester City provide the ultimate litmus test with a staggering 74 goals across all competitions this season. They average 16.2 shots per game and possess the most clinical finisher in world football, Erling Haaland, who has already amassed 20 league goals. City’s tactical setup focuses on high shot volume and sustaining pressure in the final third.
Defensive vulnerabilities on both sides make this a high-scoring probability. Newcastle are without key defensive pillars Sven Botman and Dan Burn, which directly impacts their aerial security against a City side that excels at wide deliveries. Meanwhile, City have shown a tendency to be weak at stopping opponents from creating chances on the break.
With Newcastle’s home crowd driving a high-intensity press and City’s relentless ball circulation, the game will be played in the transition. Both teams have surpassed 50 goals for the season, and their combined shot averages suggest the goalkeepers will be under constant duress throughout the 90 minutes.
What could go wrong? Newcastle’s defensive absences might force Eddie Howe into a more conservative, low-block setup to survive the first leg. If Newcastle prioritize defensive shape over their usual high-press, and City focus on recycling possession without taking risks, the game could stall into a tactical stalemate.
Correct Score Lean
Newcastle 2-2 Manchester City
Newcastle’s relentless scoring record in the EFL Cup—averaging over 2.5 goals—meets a Manchester City side that has scored 74 times this season. Newcastle are formidable at home, winning 10 of their last 13, but the absence of Botman and Burn makes keeping a clean sheet against Haaland unlikely. City often struggle to protect leads and stop transitions, which plays into the hands of Newcastle’s fast attackers like Gordon and Barnes. A high-scoring draw keeps the tie alive for the second leg at the Etihad.
Selected Bookmakers Offers
| |
New cust. Deposit £10+ in 7 days & bet on sports. Min odds apply. Reward = 4 x £10 Free Bets (2 x £10 Bet Builders & 2 x £10 Sports bet). Valid 7 days. Free bets not valid on e-sports & non UK/IE horse racing. 18+. T&Cs apply. | |
| |
Open Account Offer - New Customers only. Bet £10 and get £30 in Free Bets when you join bet365. Sign up, deposit between £5 and £10 to your account and bet365 will give you three times that value in Free Bets when you place qualifying bets to the same value settle. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits. Min odds/bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. T&Cs , time limits & exclusions apply. Registration Required. #Ad. 18+ Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
18+. Play Safe. From 00:01 on 18.10.2022. £30 bonus. New customers only. Minimum £10 stake on odds of 1/2 (1.5) or greater on sportsbook (excluding Virtual markets). Further terms apply. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New customers only. Register, deposit with Debit Card, and place first bet £10+ at Evens (2.0)+ on Sports within 7 days to get 3 x £10 in Sports Free Bets & 2 x £10 in Acca Free Bets within 10 hours of settlement. 7-day expiry. Eligibility exclusions & T&Cs Apply. | |
| |
New cust only. Opt-in required. Deposit & place a bet within 7 days and settle a £10 minimum bet at odds of 4/5 (1.8) or greater to be credited with 3 x £10 Free Bets: 1 x £10 horse racing, 1 x £10 Free Bet Builder and 1 x £10 football. Free Bets cannot be used on e-sports and non-UK/IE horse racing. 7 day expiry. Stake not returned. 18+. T&Cs apply. Acca Club: Available to new & existing customers. 3 or more selections. Min Odds: 3/10 (1.3) per leg. Max stake: £500. Max Winnings: £200,000 per boost. Profit Boost amounts vary. Horse Racing, Greyhounds & Trotting excluded. Exclusions apply. Full T&C’s apply. 18+ GambleAware.org. | |
 | |
New members only. £10+ bet on sports (ex. Virtuals) 1.5 min odds, settled within 14 days. Free Bets: accept in 7 days, valid 7 days; £20 use on sportsbook, £10 on Bet Builder. Stake not returned. T&Cs.+ deposit exclusions apply #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New bettors. Select bonus at signup or use code SPORT. Wager deposit & bonus 8x. Max qualifying bet = bonus. Valid 60 days. Odds, bet & payment limits apply. T&Cs Apply; 18+ | Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
New customers only, 18+. Min deposit £10. Place a £50 bet on any sport at 2.0+ to qualify for £25 in free bets and 10 Free Spins. Free Bets and Spins valid 7 days. £0.10 Free Spins. T&Cs apply. Please bet responsibly. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New members only. £10 min deposit & bet on sportsbook (ex. virtuals), placed & settled at 1.5 min odds in 14 days of sign-up. Win part of E/W bets. Free Bets: accept in 7 days, valid 7 days, use on sportsbook only (ex. virtuals), stakes not returned. T&Cs Apply and deposit exclusions apply. Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
18+ New customers only. Opt in, and bet £10 on football markets (odds 2.00+). No cash out. Get 6x£5 football free bets at specified odds for set markets, which expire after 7 days. Offer valid from 12:00 UK Time on 25/08/2023. Card payments only. T&Cs Apply | gambleaware.org | Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
