York City vs Oldham Predictions

York City vs Oldham predictions for Tuesday’s National League clash at LNER Community Stadium. York City host Oldham Athletic at the LNER Community Stadium on Tuesday evening in their National League playoff semi-final. Read on for all our free betting tips and predictions.

National League | May 20 2025 at 7:45pm UK at Dwight Yorke Stadium

York City vs Oldham Predictions

Can York City’s Home Form Prove Too Much for Oldham in Playoff Semi-Final?

• Home Comforts: York have won 16 of their 23 home league matches this season, a formidable record that underlines their strength at the LNER Community Stadium.
• Pearce’s Goal Machine: York striker Ollie Pearce has scored 31 goals in 45 league appearances this term, making him the top marksman in the division.
• Oldham’s Travel Woes: The visitors have failed to win in any of their last three visits to York, each ending in a 1-1 stalemate.

Best Bet for York City vs Oldham

York City’s journey back to the English Football League is just two games away from completion, but first, they must navigate a tricky National League playoff semi-final against Oldham Athletic at the LNER Community Stadium on Tuesday night. It’s a clash between two sides with vastly different recent histories. York, once a League Two staple, have battled their way through a gruelling campaign to finish second, narrowly missing out on automatic promotion to Barnet. Despite their disappointment, the Minstermen can take heart from an eight-match unbeaten streak that saw them win seven and draw one, a run that helped them secure this semi-final berth without the need for a quarter-final scrap.

Oldham, on the other hand, are no strangers to the pressure of knockout football, having thrashed Halifax Town 4-0 in their quarter-final tie to earn their spot in this clash. While York’s recent form and formidable home record make them the favourites, the Latics can draw on their own proud history, albeit a distant one, as they seek a return to the EFL for the first time in over three decades. However, they have struggled at the LNER Community Stadium, failing to win on any of their three previous visits, all of which ended in 1-1 draws. Will Oldham’s quarter-final confidence carry them past their hosts, or will York’s fortress prove too daunting once again?

Best Bet for York City vs Oldham Athletic: York City to Win and Over 2.5 Goals

Here at BettingTips4You.com, we pride ourselves on delivering just one carefully selected prediction per match – no confusing lists of alternatives, just the single, ultimate tip for each event. For this crucial semi-final, our best bet is York City to Win and Over 2.5 Goals.

Rationale

York City have been imperious at home this season, recording 16 wins, four draws, and just three defeats at the LNER Community Stadium. Their attack has been spearheaded by the prolific Ollie Pearce, who has racked up a stunning 31 goals in 45 league appearances. Pearce’s sharp finishing and relentless work rate make him the standout threat in this contest, and he will undoubtedly be the focal point of York’s attacking efforts.

Oldham, while capable of the occasional explosive performance – as seen in their 4-0 demolition of Halifax – have been less consistent away from home, losing four of their final seven regular-season matches. They also have a poor record against York, failing to win on their last three trips to the LNER Community Stadium. With York enjoying a 15-day rest before this clash, their fresher legs and home comforts could prove decisive.

Additionally, York’s recent scoring form is impossible to ignore. The Minstermen ended their campaign with seven wins from eight, netting multiple goals in the majority of those encounters. Oldham’s defence, which conceded twice to York earlier in the season, will have their work cut out trying to contain Pearce and his supporting cast.

BettingTips4You.com expert Herrin Kendrick sums it up perfectly:

“When you combine York’s relentless home form, their talismanic goalscorer in Pearce, and a fresher squad after a 15-day break, it’s hard to see anything other than a high-scoring home win here. Oldham may put up a fight, but York should have too much quality on the day.”

Predicted Scoreline: York City 3-1 Oldham Athletic. York’s attacking firepower, coupled with Oldham’s shaky away form, points to a confident home win, with Pearce likely to be among the goals once again.

---

Want to have exclusive tips from experts tipsters delivered right into your inbox? Subscribe Now To Our Newsletter. We will never spam, we fully respect your privacy!

Selected Bookmakers Offers