Toronto vs New York Red Bulls Predictions

Toronto vs New York Red Bulls Predictions for this MLS Playoffs. Toronto host New York Red Bulls in game four of a five-match MLS homestand on Wednesday at BMO Field, seeking crucial points to boost their campaign. Read on for our free betting tips and predictions.

MLS Playoffs | June 26 2025 at 12:30 am UK at BMO Field

Toronto vs New York Red Bulls Predictions

Is Another Frustrating Night Looming for Toronto at BMO Field?

• Toronto’s Home Woes Continue: The Canadian side have lost four straight at BMO Field and failed to score in six home MLS games this season. The fans deserve refunds at this point.
• Red Bulls Thrive Against Weaker Sides: New York have won four of their last five matches against Eastern Conference teams below them in the table—flat-track bullies, some might say.
• Choupo-Moting the Road Warrior: Six of his 10 goals this campaign have come away from home, making him a serious threat in this fixture despite the travel miles.

Best Bet for Toronto vs New York Red Bulls

The pressure is reaching boiling point in Toronto, and Wednesday night’s fixture against the New York Red Bulls could either spark a turnaround or deepen the crisis for Robin Fraser’s side. As they host the Red Bulls in game four of a five-match MLS homestand, the mood around BMO Field feels more anxious than optimistic. The crowd wants answers, and the pitch hasn’t been delivering any.

Toronto head into this one looking desperately short on confidence and even shorter on results. Their 2-0 defeat to Charlotte last time out wasn’t just another loss—it was a continuation of a miserable run that’s now stretched to three straight league defeats. That 6-1 demolition of Montreal in May might’ve fooled a few into thinking they’d turned a corner, but reality has hit hard since then. They’ve now lost four home games on the bounce, equalling their longest-ever winless streak at BMO Field, and goals have been painfully scarce—especially on home turf.

In contrast, the Red Bulls aren’t exactly setting the world alight, but they’ve been better—just. Their loss to Austin was a setback, but it ended a solid four-game winning streak. They’ve found ways to win against weaker Eastern Conference sides, and they’ve been particularly ruthless when netting more than once, going unbeaten in those matches this season. Given Toronto’s attacking bluntness and inability to hold onto leads, that might be all New York need to get the job done again.

Best Bet for Toronto vs New York Red Bulls: New York Red Bulls to Win

We’ve gone through all the numbers, scanned the team news, and considered the situational factors, and our standout recommendation is clear: New York Red Bulls to win. At BettingTips4You.com, we don’t believe in overcomplicating things. One match, one prediction—that’s our golden rule. It keeps things honest, accountable, and far more effective than juggling three or four half-baked ideas.

Why this particular selection? Well, let’s start with the basics. Toronto simply don’t look like a team that can get out of their own way at the moment. They’ve lost eight straight against New York-based teams and haven’t beaten the Red Bulls in MLS since before some of their fans probably even started shaving. In their last four league outings at home, they haven’t picked up a single point, and in more than half their home games this season, they haven’t even managed to score. That’s not just bad luck—that’s systemic failure in the final third.

New York, despite their wobbles on the road, still bring far more balance to the table. They’ve managed wins in four of their last five matches against Eastern teams sitting below them in the standings, and they’ve shown they can exploit fragile opponents. With Carlos Coronel expected back in goal and Wiktor Bogacz also returning from international duty, they’ll be close to full strength—unlike Toronto, who are without multiple first-team players due to injury and Gold Cup duty. Factor in the form of Eric-Maxim Choupo-Moting, who’s been particularly effective on the road, and it’s difficult to make a case for the home side.

“There’s nothing more dangerous than a side who knows how to beat teams worse than them—and that’s exactly what New York are right now,”
*— BettingTips4You.com expert Mark Wighan “Toronto just can’t seem to land a punch, even at home.”

---

Correct Score Prediction: Toronto 1-2 New York Red Bulls

Toronto may get on the board, possibly via a set-piece or a moment of individual brilliance, but the likelihood of them keeping the Red Bulls out feels slim. Expect the visitors to strike early, hold control, and find a second when the game opens up.

Selected Bookmakers Offers