Sheffield Wednesday vs Grimsby Town Predictions

Sheffield Wednesday vs Grimsby Town predictions for Tuesday’s Carabao Cup tie. Grimsby Town, League Two underdogs, visit Sheffield Wednesday in Tuesday’s EFL Cup third-round clash at Hillsborough, aiming to cause another upset against Championship opposition. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

EFL Cup | Sep 16 2025 at 7:45 pm UK at Hillsborough Stadium

Sheffield Wednesday vs Grimsby Town Predictions

Could this cup clash swing the way nobody expects?

• Defensive frailty continues
  • Sheffield Wednesday have failed to record a clean sheet since March, and across all competitions they have conceded multiple goals in six of their last seven games.
• Mariners’ scoring streak on the road
  • Grimsby Town have found the net in every away fixture this campaign, scoring three at MK Dons and snatching a dramatic point at Cambridge United.
• Goals expected from both sides
  • With the Owls struggling at Hillsborough and Grimsby buoyed by their Manchester United scalp, this match almost screams for goals at both ends of the pitch.

Best Bet for Sheffield Wednesday vs Grimsby Town

Cup nights at Hillsborough have always carried a certain bite, and this week’s third-round tie has all the makings of a real drama. Sheffield Wednesday, battered and bruised from a poor run in the Championship, suddenly find themselves staring down the barrel of another early-season crisis. Their league form has been dire, with defeats piling up and goals proving almost impossible to come by. Yet, paradoxically, it is in the EFL Cup where they have momentarily remembered how to fight, having knocked out Bolton on penalties and then stunned Leeds in another shoot-out.

Grimsby Town arrive with their tails up after a remarkable summer of battling performances. The Mariners may ply their trade two divisions below, but under David Artell they have become something of a stubborn outfit. The unforgettable penalty victory over Manchester United was a reminder of just how dangerous a lower-league side can be when belief is coursing through their veins. Their away record has been quietly impressive too, and the fact they sit fifth in League Two shows they are not here to merely make up the numbers. The stage feels set for another tense night under the Hillsborough lights, with both sides sensing an opportunity but neither able to fully trust themselves.

---

Best Bet for this match

Here at BettingTips4You we never drown you in countless selections. We stand by a single tip, the ultimate choice, the one bet that rises above the noise. That’s why our Best Bet for this fixture is backing both teams to score. Among all possible markets, this is the standout, the bet that captures exactly how this tie is likely to unravel.

Why go down this route? Let’s face it, Sheffield Wednesday are leaking goals at an alarming rate. They haven’t managed a clean sheet since March and their defence looks more like an open invitation than a barricade. Against Swansea and Bristol City they were sliced apart with ease, and even Championship opponents struggling for form have taken advantage of their soft underbelly. At the same time, Wednesday’s attack is not firing on all cylinders. Barry Bannan continues to orchestrate in midfield and Jamal Lowe adds movement up top, but too often their chances fade into frustration.

Grimsby, meanwhile, thrive in chaos. Jaze Kabia, supported by Darragh Burns and Charles Vernam, gives them a fluid front line capable of nicking goals against anyone. The Mariners have scored in every away game this season, including three at MK Dons, so there’s no reason to think they’ll draw a blank against a Championship side whose back three of Max Lowe, Gabriel Otegbayo and Ernie Weaver have looked shaky under pressure.

What makes this selection even stronger is the mindset of both teams. For Sheffield Wednesday, this is a chance to stop the rot, but nerves are bound to creep in. For Grimsby, it’s a free hit, and that fearless approach often results in chances being taken. Put simply, this game has both teams finding the net written all over it.

As BettingTips4You.com expert Graham Hartshorn put it:

“When a Championship side struggling for goals meets a League Two team who refuse to stop scoring, the only logical conclusion is that both nets will be rattled. Form may wobble, confidence may fluctuate, but goals are unavoidable here.”

Looking at the bigger picture, a scoreline such as 2-2 feels entirely plausible. Wednesday’s home record has been poor all year, while Grimsby have made a habit of staying alive deep into games, snatching late equalisers and thriving under pressure. If Wednesday do manage to squeeze more from their attacking pair of Lowe and Cadamarteri, then goals will come. But given their defensive vulnerability, it’s hard to imagine the Mariners not taking advantage of the cracks.

So while some punters may be tempted by the outright upset, the safer and more balanced call remains both teams to score. It carries value, it reflects the reality of both squads, and it ties neatly with the wider pattern of recent matches. The beauty of this pick is that you don’t even need to pick a winner to cash in – you just need both sides to do what they’ve been doing all season: conceding and scoring in equal measure.

Correct score prediction

The most likely outcome looks a thrilling 2-2 draw. Wednesday’s defensive woes suggest they will not keep Grimsby quiet, while the Championship side should still have enough attacking talent to prevent outright elimination in normal time.

Selected Bookmakers Offers