Salford City vs Rotherham United Predictions

Salford City vs Rotherham United predictions for this clash in the EFL Cup. Salford City host Rotherham United at the Peninsula Stadium on Tuesday in the first round of the 2025–26 EFL Cup. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

 EFL Cup | Aug 12 2025 at 7:45 pm UK at the Peninsula Stadium

Salford City vs Rotherham United Predictions

Will Rotherham’s Extra Edge Be Enough to End Salford’s Cup Hopes?

• Salford have failed to win seven of their last eight competitive home matches, conceding in six of those.
• Rotherham have scored two or more goals in half of their last ten victories across all competitions, showing a strong conversion rate when they win.
• Salford’s last five EFL Cup matches have all seen both teams score, underlining their vulnerability at the back in knockout football.

Best Bet for Salford City vs Rotherham United

Salford City and Rotherham United meet at the Peninsula Stadium on Tuesday night in what promises to be a fascinating EFL Cup first-round tie.
For the Ammies, there’s a whiff of revenge in the air – they might not have suffered against Rotherham recently, but cup nights carry a history of their own, and everyone in this part of Greater Manchester knows that the mood around the club lifts instantly with a scalp against higher-league opposition.

Salford arrive buoyed by their 2-1 away win at Notts County, a result that was as gritty as it was deserved. Adebola Oluwo’s opener and Kelly N’Mai’s cool finish put them in the driving seat before a nervous final 20 minutes saw them hang on. Before that, the summer had been decent – unbeaten in pre-season – but the memory of an opening-day home loss to Crewe still stings.
Rotherham, meanwhile, have that frustrating combination of threat and inconsistency. They opened League One with a smart 2-1 win at Port Vale, Sam Nombe showing his sharpness, only to be blunt in a 1-0 defeat to Stevenage last weekend. That drop-off is exactly what Salford will hope to exploit, though the Millers still carry enough quality and physical presence to make them dangerous opponents.

Best Bet for this match: Rotherham to Win

Here at BettingTips4You, we make life simple – one game, one bet, the best pick. No overloading you with five different options. Just the tip we truly believe has the strongest value, and for this one, it’s Rotherham to take the win in 90 minutes. It’s not just the league gap speaking – it’s the combination of their attacking potential and Salford’s shaky home record.

Salford might have picked up that crucial away victory at Meadow Lane, but their form at the Peninsula Stadium is a different beast altogether. One win in eight competitive home fixtures is hardly the record of a side you can trust to topple a higher-tier opponent. Rotherham, even with the frustration of the Stevenage loss, have shown they can create and finish chances, especially when they impose themselves physically. They might not always dominate possession, but they tend to convert their spells of pressure into goals.

Defensively, Salford still leave gaps – the loss to Crewe and the nervy ending at Notts County both exposed that. Rotherham’s front line, even if Nombe isn’t fully fit, has options that can punish lapses. And it’s worth noting, the Millers have enough steel in midfield to disrupt Salford’s rhythm early on, which could tilt the balance.

As BettingTips4You.com expert Steve Harrington put it:

“Cup football isn’t about romance when you’re chasing promotion – it’s about doing the job quickly. Rotherham’s extra quality and physicality should see them through, even if it’s not always pretty.”

I’m expecting the Millers to manage the game professionally – taking their moments and keeping Salford at arm’s length. The gulf might not look massive on paper over 90 minutes, but in the decisive phases, Rotherham’s edge should tell.

Predicted correct score: Salford City 1-2 Rotherham United – Salford will compete and might even score first, but the visitors’ greater depth and composure should see them turn it around.

Selected Bookmakers Offers