Rotherham vs Wycombe Wanderers Predictions

Rotherham vs Wycombe predictions for this match in League One. Wycombe Wanderers can move into League One’s automatic promotion spots with a win against Rotherham United at the New York Stadium on Tuesday. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

League One | Mar 18, 2025 at 7.45pm UK at New York Stadium

Rotherham vs Wycombe Wanderers Predictions

Wycombe’s Promotion Push Faces Rotherham Test – Will They Deliver Under Pressure?

• Wycombe’s attacking firepower but away struggles
  • Despite being League One’s top scorers with 61 goals, Wycombe have failed to win any of their last five away matches, drawing three and losing two.
• Rotherham’s home form shows goals are likely
  • The Millers have scored in seven of their last eight home games, proving they tend to find the net at the New York Stadium even when their overall form is inconsistent.
• A history of goals in Wycombe’s away matches
  • Eight of Wycombe’s last 10 away league matches have ended with both teams scoring, making BTTS a strong statistical pick for this fixture.

Best Bet for Rotherham vs Wycombe Wanderers

Wycombe Wanderers are heading into a crucial Tuesday night showdown with Rotherham United, knowing that a victory will propel them into the automatic promotion spots in League One. The stakes could hardly be higher for the visitors, who have been among the most potent attacking forces in the division but have shown inconsistency in recent weeks. On the other hand, Rotherham, sitting in 14th place, have nothing to lose and will be eager to play the role of spoilers at the New York Stadium.

While Wycombe have been one of the most dominant sides in League One this season, their recent form is far from perfect. Their 1-0 defeat to Wrexham last time out was a bitter blow, not just because it widened the gap between the two promotion rivals, but also because it exposed some weaknesses in their ability to break down disciplined defences. They will need to be sharper in the final third against a Rotherham side that, despite their inconsistent season, can be difficult to break down at home.

Rotherham come into this game on the back of a 1-1 draw with Exeter City, a match in which they created plenty of chances but ultimately failed to capitalise. That has been a recurring theme for them, as they have blanked in three of their last seven matches and rarely score more than once per game. However, their home record shows signs of promise, having found the net in seven of their last eight games at the New York Stadium. If Wycombe’s defence isn’t at its best, the Millers could well cause them problems.

Despite Rotherham’s ability to get on the scoresheet, their record against Wycombe does not inspire much confidence. They lost 2-0 in the reverse fixture earlier in the campaign and have won just one of the last ten meetings between the sides. Given Wycombe’s pressing need for three points, they will likely go on the front foot from the start. The question is whether their attack, which has been the best in the league but has also misfired at times, can deliver on the night.

Best Bet for Rotherham vs Wycombe

At BettingTips4You, we focus on quality over quantity, meaning we do not throw out multiple conflicting predictions for a single game. Instead, we carefully analyse every aspect and deliver only the best possible bet—the one that offers the strongest value based on form, stats, and tactical matchups.

For this encounter, the standout selection is Both Teams to Score (BTTS). Rotherham’s scoring record at home suggests they will contribute to the tally, while Wycombe’s attacking firepower should be enough to breach the Millers’ backline.

---

Why Both Teams to Score is the Best Bet for This Match

Wycombe’s goalscoring prowess is undeniable. Their tally of 61 goals this season is the highest in League One, proving that they have the attacking tools to break through any defence. However, they have been prone to off-days, particularly away from home, where they have failed to win any of their last five matches.

Rotherham, meanwhile, have scored in seven of their last eight home games, which suggests they are more than capable of getting on the scoresheet, especially against a Wycombe side that has conceded 1.28 goals per away game this season. While the Millers’ attack has been inconsistent overall, they did create plenty of chances against Exeter, registering 2.33 expected goals (xG) in that match. If they bring that same level of creativity, they should at least trouble Wycombe’s defence.

Defensively, neither team looks particularly solid. Rotherham have conceded in four of their last five home matches, while Wycombe’s struggles on the road have seen them let in goals far too frequently. The fact that Wycombe have managed just two wins from their last nine games further emphasises their vulnerability, and even though they have dominated this fixture historically, it’s unlikely they will have it all their own way this time.

BettingTips4You.com expert quote:
“Wycombe have the firepower to win this game, but their defensive issues cannot be ignored. Rotherham will see this as a free hit, and with their ability to score at home, both teams getting on the scoresheet looks a solid bet. Wycombe’s promotion push could be thrilling, but it won’t be easy.”

Looking at previous trends, eight of Wycombe’s last 10 away matches have seen both teams score, which strongly supports this prediction. They have only failed to find the net in one away game this season (against Birmingham), meaning they are highly likely to score at the New York Stadium. However, their defensive record on the road suggests they will not keep a clean sheet either.

Given all these factors, a 2-1 victory for Wycombe looks like the most probable outcome. They are the stronger side, and with promotion at stake, they should find a way to edge past Rotherham. However, it is unlikely to be a straightforward win, and the Millers could make life difficult for them before ultimately falling short.Wycombe’s defence.

Want to have exclusive tips from experts tipsters delivered right into your inbox? Subscribe Now To Our Newsletter. We will never spam, we fully respect your privacy!

Selected Bookmakers Offers