👇 Choose your bookmaker — tap a logo to claim exclusive sign-up bonuses and free bets.
18+; #Ad; Please Bet Responsibly
Rotherham United vs Oldham Athletic Predictions predictions for this EFL Trophy. The Aesseal New York Stadium will host a tense Tuesday evening affair as Rotherham United welcome Oldham Athletic in the EFL Trophy. Read on for all of our free German Bundesliga betting tips and predictions.
▾
Backing Over 2.5 Goals fits this tie: Rotherham’s fragile back line and lively attack, plus Oldham’s openness and cup rotation, point to an end-to-end contest where control slips and chances keep flowing.
▾
Rotherham carry greater depth at home and should edge chaotic phases; Oldham threaten periodically, but pressure suggests a 3–1 outcome.
Rotherham United vs Oldham Athletic Predictions and Best Bets
- Leaky Defences on Display – Rotherham have conceded fifteen goals in League One and failed to keep a clean sheet in ten of their last eleven matches.
- High-Scoring Trends in Cup Play – Oldham’s EFL Trophy campaign began with a wild 5-1 loss, while Rotherham’s last two games have averaged over 3.5 total goals.
- Both Sides Struggling for Consistency – Between them, Rotherham and Oldham have managed just two wins in their last ten combined fixtures, highlighting defensive fragility but attacking unpredictability.
Can Rotherham End Their Drought or Will Oldham Pull Off an EFL Trophy Upset?
Both sides arrive at this clash nursing bruised egos and searching for a performance that can spark a reaction. For Rotherham, the past month has been a frustrating one, filled with missed opportunities, defensive lapses, and a winless run that has left supporters sighing in disbelief. Celebrating their centenary season, the Millers would dearly love to inject some pride into their campaign — and the EFL Trophy might just be their best chance to do so.
Oldham, on the other hand, are coming off a stinging 3-1 defeat to Notts County that halted their momentum. It’s been a campaign of extremes for the Latics: moments of genuine promise followed by sudden dips in form. Their opening EFL Trophy fixture — a humbling 5-1 loss to Manchester City’s Under-21s — served as a painful reminder of the gap in quality when they lose their shape. Still, facing a struggling Rotherham side might just give them a glimmer of hope.
Both sides have something to prove here, though for very different reasons. For the Millers, this competition could be a lifeline to restore belief; for Oldham, it’s an opportunity to test themselves against higher-level opposition and rebuild some self-respect.
Best Bet for this Match: Over 2.5 Goals
Here at BettingTips4You, we don’t flood readers with dozens of different markets. We believe in one match, one crystal-clear prediction — the Best Bet — because quality beats quantity every time. Our analysis points firmly towards one outcome for this game: Over 2.5 Goals. This is the selection we’re standing by, and it’s the one that provides the best balance of value, logic, and likelihood.
Why do we expect goals? Because both of these teams simply can’t help but concede and create chaos. Rotherham’s defensive record tells its own story — fifteen goals conceded in their League One campaign so far, with only one clean sheet in their last ten matches. Their most recent 2-2 draw with Bradford City summed up their season perfectly: moments of attacking promise quickly undone by lapses at the back. You could almost hear the collective groan around the ground as a two-goal lead evaporated into thin air.
And then there’s Oldham. Their 5-1 collapse against Manchester City’s academy side wasn’t just a bad day — it exposed a side that struggles to maintain structure when pressed. Yet going forward, the Latics aren’t toothless. In recent weeks they’ve managed to score in five of their last six outings, showing enough attacking ambition to suggest they can trouble a shaky Rotherham backline. Players like Kai Payne and James Quigley bring mobility and sharpness, and that could cause problems for Rotherham’s patched-up defence.
With both sides prone to errors but still capable of producing moments of attacking flair, this match has “open contest” written all over it. Rotherham’s home advantage might tilt the balance slightly in their favour, but expecting a cagey, low-scoring affair here would be naive.
BettingTips4You.com expert Steve Harrington put it best when he said:
William Hill
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
BetMGM
Bet £10 Get £40 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
bet365
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Betfred
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
10bet
100% Up To £50 On First Deposit
Show Terms & Conditions
“When two defensively fragile teams meet, it’s rarely a stalemate. Both sides will fancy their chances and that’s usually the recipe for goals, not clean sheets.
Based on the form and the patterns of play, we’re forecasting Over 2.5 Goals as the strongest betting angle. Expect some heart-stopping moments at both ends, but in the end, Rotherham’s extra quality should see them edge a lively encounter. A 3-1 home win feels the most realistic outcome — enough to calm the nerves in South Yorkshire, at least temporarily.
Selected Bookmakers Offers
| |
New customers only. 7 days to place qualifying bet of £10 at 1/1 (2.0) to receive 4 x £10 Free Bets: 1 x £10 football, 1 x £10 horse racing & 2 x £10 Bet Builders. Free Bets cannot be used on e-sports and non-UK/IE horse racing. 7 day expiry. Exclusions apply. Stake not returned. 18+. Full T&Cs apply. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
Open Account Offer – New Customers only. Bet £10 and get £30 in Free Bets when you join bet365. Sign up, deposit between £5 and £10 to your account and bet365 will give you five times that value in Free Bets when you place qualifying bets to the same value settle. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits. Min odds/bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. T&Cs , time limits & exclusions apply. Registration Required. #Ad. 18+ Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
18+. Play Safe. From 00:01 on 18.10.2022. £30 bonus. New customers only. Minimum £10 stake on odds of 1/2 (1.5) or greater on sportsbook (excluding Virtual markets). Further terms apply. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New customers only. Register, deposit with Debit Card, and place first bet £10+ at Evens (2.0)+ on Sports within 7 days to get 3 x £10 in Sports Free Bets & 2 x £10 in Acca Free Bets within 10 hours of settlement. 7-day expiry. Eligibility exclusions & T&Cs Apply. | |
| |
New cust only. Opt-in required. Deposit & place a bet within 7 days and settle a £10 minimum bet at odds of 4/5 (1.8) or greater to be credited with 3 x £10 Free Bets: 1 x £10 horse racing, 1 x £10 Free Bet Builder and 1 x £10 football. Free Bets cannot be used on e-sports and non-UK/IE horse racing. 7 day expiry. Stake not returned. 18+. T&Cs apply. Acca Club: Available to new & existing customers. 3 or more selections. Min Odds: 3/10 (1.3) per leg. Max stake: £500. Max Winnings: £200,000 per boost. Profit Boost amounts vary. Horse Racing, Greyhounds & Trotting excluded. Exclusions apply. Full T&C’s apply. 18+ GambleAware.org. | |
 | |
New members only. £10+ bet on sportsbook (ex. virtuals) at 1.5 min odds, settled within 14 days. Free Bets: accept in 7 days, valid 7 days on sportsbook only. 2x£5 Free Bets for Bet Builder only. Stake not returned. T&Cs + deposit exclusions apply. T&Cs.+ deposit exclusions apply #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New bettors. Select bonus at signup or use code SPORT. Wager deposit & bonus 8x. Max qualifying bet = bonus. Valid 60 days. Odds, bet & payment limits apply. T&Cs Apply; 18+ | Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
New customers only, 18+. Min deposit £10. Place a £50 bet on any sport at 2.0+ to qualify for £25 in free bets and 10 Free Spins. Free Bets and Spins valid 7 days. £0.10 Free Spins. T&Cs apply. Please bet responsibly. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
New members only. £10 min deposit & bet on sportsbook (ex. virtuals), placed & settled at 1.5 min odds in 14 days of sign-up. Win part of E/W bets. Free Bets: accept in 7 days, valid 7 days, use on sportsbook only (ex. virtuals), stakes not returned. T&Cs Apply and deposit exclusions apply. Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
18+ New customers only. Opt in, and bet £10 on football markets (odds 2.00+). No cash out. Get 6x£5 football free bets at specified odds for set markets, which expire after 7 days. Offer valid from 12:00 UK Time on 25/08/2023. Card payments only. T&Cs Apply | gambleaware.org | Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
