Plymouth Argyle vs Cheltenham Town Predictions

Plymouth Argyle vs Cheltenham Town predictions for this EFL Trophy. Plymouth Argyle host Cheltenham Town on Tuesday night, seeking a winning start to their 2025-26 EFL Trophy campaign against the League Two side. Read on for our free match preview and betting tips.

EFL Trophy | Sep 2 2025 at 7:00 pm UK at Home Park

Plymouth Argyle vs Cheltenham Town Predictions

Will Plymouth’s Extra Quality Shine Through Against Struggling Cheltenham?

• Plymouth’s patchy start
  • The Greens have taken only three points from their opening six league games, underlining why this cup clash carries importance for morale.
• Cheltenham’s nightmare run
  • With just one point from six League Two matches, the Robins sit bottom of the table and have already tasted defeat five times this season.
• Goals expected either way
  • Four of Cheltenham’s last five losses in all competitions have featured two or more goals, showing how often their defence gets pulled apart.

Best Bet for Plymouth Argyle vs Cheltenham Town

Tuesday evening sees Home Park play host to an EFL Trophy clash between two sides who desperately need a lift. Plymouth Argyle, fresh from a bruising 4-0 defeat away to Cardiff City, are in search of something to restore belief. The Greens, having dropped out of the Championship last term, have found the start to life in League One anything but forgiving. Just one victory from six matches paints a grim picture, and Tom Cleverley must be aware that more slip-ups could pile on unwanted pressure.

Cheltenham Town, however, are hardly arriving with their chests puffed out. Rooted to the bottom of League Two, Michael Flynn’s men have only managed a solitary point so far. Their draw at Salford might have halted the losing streak, but it hardly screams revival. The Robins have struggled at both ends of the pitch, and their league position reflects it.

While both managers will rotate with the weekend fixtures in mind, this game carries weight. Plymouth need to avoid spiralling deeper into doubt, and Cheltenham must find a way to compete or risk being swatted aside again. It may not be a glamour tie, but the stakes—morale, confidence, momentum—are very real.

---

Best Bet for this match

At BettingTips4You, we do things differently. We don’t flood you with endless options or half-baked punts. We stand by one carefully selected prediction for each game—the Best Bet. That way, there’s no confusion, no hedging—just one tip that we truly believe gives you the edge.

For Plymouth Argyle v Cheltenham Town, our Best Bet is Plymouth Argyle to win and over 1.5 goals in the match.

The reasoning is straightforward yet compelling. Plymouth, even in their struggles, have more firepower and depth than Cheltenham. The likes of Aribim Pepple and Owen Oseni bring energy up front, while the creativity of Joseph Hatch and Freddie Issaka can break down a shaky visiting backline. Cheltenham, meanwhile, are bottom of League Two for a reason: one point from six matches tells its own story. Their defence has been breached too often, with Cardiff recently hitting three past them in the EFL Cup and Salford still finding a way through at the weekend.

Yes, Plymouth conceded four against Cardiff, but that was against stronger opposition. Against a side lacking belief and confidence like Cheltenham, the Greens’ second string should have enough. This fixture is less about the glamour names and more about squad depth, and on that front Plymouth are stronger. With Zak Baker expected in goal and Brendan Galloway likely to steady the back line, the hosts should have a solid platform to build on.

As Graham Hartshorn from BettingTips4You.com neatly summed it up:

“Plymouth may not be flying, but against Cheltenham’s fragile defence they won’t need to be. The Greens should get the job done with goals to spare.”

Expecting Plymouth to dominate completely might be too optimistic given their current mood, but they should win. Adding over 1.5 goals brings value because both teams’ form points towards multiple strikes. A 2-0 or 2-1 feels realistic, but our lean is towards a 2-0 home success, reflecting Plymouth’s superior quality and Cheltenham’s glaring weaknesses.

Selected Bookmakers Offers