Orlando City vs New York City Predictions

Orlando City vs New York City predictions for this match in MLS. New York City FC visit Orlando City Wednesday at Inter & Co Stadium in game two of their four-match MLS road trip, seeking vital away points. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

MLS | Jul 17 2025 at 12:30 am UK at Orlando City Stadium

Orlando City vs New York City Predictions

Can Orlando’s Home Form Outweigh NYCFC’s Travelling Troubles?

• Orlando City’s Leaky Defence at Home: The Lions have conceded six goals across their last three matches at Inter & Co Stadium, failing to win any of those.
• NYCFC’s Road Woes Continue: New York City FC have lost nine of their last ten away league fixtures, scoring just eight times in those ten outings.
• High Probability of Goals: Three of Orlando’s last four matches have produced over 2.5 goals, underlining the attacking intent and defensive gaps of both sides.

Best Bet for Orlando City vs New York City

The stage is set at Inter & Co Stadium this Wednesday, where Orlando City will take on New York City FC in a game that might not set fire to the MLS table, but certainly won’t be short of intrigue. With both sides nestled in the middle of the Eastern Conference pack, this is a clash with implications for the playoff picture, and neither will want to slip further into mid-table obscurity.

Orlando find themselves slightly better placed going into this encounter, sitting sixth, with four points separating them from their upcoming opponents. However, if recent form is anything to go by, confidence isn’t exactly flowing. A frustrating 1-1 draw at home to CF Montreal last time out extended their winless run to three, and defensive lapses have haunted them recently — six goals shipped in their last three at home tells its own tale.

As for NYCFC, inconsistency might as well be their middle name this season. Pascal Jansen’s side continue to trip over themselves, managing just two wins from their last six matches, and the away form is simply woeful. A 2-0 loss to Charlotte in their most recent outing was the latest reminder that they struggle on the road, having lost nine of their last ten away games.

Yet, this is football — and with both teams fighting for postseason relevance, tension, goals and the odd meltdown are all very much on the cards.

Best Bet for This Match: Over 2.5 Goals

At BettingTips4You, we believe in quality over quantity. That’s why we don’t throw a dozen bets your way and leave you to guess — we cut through the noise and deliver one top-tier prediction for every clash. And for this intriguing MLS showdown, our best bet is Over 2.5 Goals.

Why? Well, let’s start with Orlando. Despite their patchy form, they’ve still managed to score in 12 of their last 13 league matches. They’ve also hit three or more goals in seven MLS games this season, which speaks volumes about their attacking ability — particularly at home, where they’ve found the net in all but one fixture.

Defensively, though, the Lions are anything but kings at the back. Recent home games have exposed cracks, and they’ve conceded six in their last three at Inter & Co Stadium. That kind of vulnerability will surely have NYCFC licking their lips, even with their well-documented away issues.

The visitors, for all their inconsistency, still pack a punch going forward. With Hannes Wolf and Alonso Martínez combining for 17 goals this season, there’s a real threat when they find rhythm. And rhythm they’ll need, considering they’ve scored just eight goals away from home this season. Even so, Orlando’s leaky defence might be just the opportunity they need to improve that average.

Combine Orlando’s attacking instinct with their defensive wobbles and throw in a NYCFC side desperate to turn things around, and you’ve got all the ingredients for a match where keeping the scoreline low feels almost impossible.

BettingTips4You.com expert quote:

“Both these sides are too flawed to keep things tight — and too talented not to score. Over 2.5 goals is the sweet spot for value in what should be a wildly open game.” – Steve Harrington

The way this is shaping up, we’re anticipating goals. Not necessarily beautiful goals. Maybe a tap-in here, a defensive error there, and perhaps even a bizarre VAR decision for good measure. But goals nonetheless.

If you’re asking for a scoreline? We’re backing a 2-1 win for Orlando City. Their superior home scoring form, combined with NYCFC’s travel sickness, tilts the balance just enough in their favour — but don’t expect them to keep a clean sheet.

Selected Bookmakers Offers