Nashville SC vs New York City Predictions

Nashville SC vs New York City predictions ahead of this clash in MLS on Saturday night. New York City FC visit Geodis Park on Saturday aiming to inflict Nashville SC’s second home defeat of the 2025 MLS season in a key Eastern Conference clash. Read on for our free betting tips and predictions.

Major League Soccer | May 31 2025 at 9:30 pm UK at Geodis Park

Nashville SC vs New York City Predictions

Can Nashville SC Maintain Their Fortress or Will NYCFC Finally Break Through on the Road?

• Nashville’s Home Strength is Undeniable
• The Boys in Gold have won four of their last five home games, averaging over two goals per match in that stretch.
• NYCFC’s Travelling Woes Continue
• New York City have managed just two wins from their last 19 away fixtures, failing to score in several of those matches.
• Defensive Discipline at GEODIS Park
• Nashville have conceded one or fewer in seven of their last eight at home, including two clean sheets against NYCFC in past meetings.

Best Bet for Nashville SC vs New York City

It’s a matchup between one of the league’s strongest home outfits and a team that travels like they’ve forgotten what an away win feels like. On Saturday night at GEODIS Park, Nashville SC look to extend their impressive home run when they host a volatile New York City FC side whose form depends entirely on the zip code. For the hosts, this is a golden opportunity to underline their top-three credentials and remind the rest of the Eastern Conference that nobody waltzes into Music City and leaves singing.

Fresh off a frustrating yet hard-earned 2-2 draw with the Columbus Crew, Nashville sit third in the table, riding an unbeaten wave that now stretches to nine matches in all competitions. And while they dropped points midweek despite leading twice, they’re finding consistency in results and resilience in defence. Joe Willis keeps clocking milestones, the backline refuses to panic, and when Sam Surridge and Hany Mukhtar get a sniff, there’s usually something to celebrate. Even with a few injuries to contend with, this side is purring like a southern V8.

Meanwhile, NYCFC arrive with a bruised ego after getting dismantled 3-0 by Houston Dynamo. They conceded as many in that game as they had in their previous seven matches combined. That kind of defensive collapse doesn’t inspire much confidence when preparing to face a Nashville side who average more than two goals per game at home. And the Pigeons don’t exactly soar on the road—unless you count short-haul domestic nightmares. One win away all season. Two in their last 19 on the road. This isn’t travel sickness, it’s a full-blown allergy.

Best Bet for Nashville SC vs New York City FC: Nashville -1 to Win

At BettingTips4You.com, we’re committed to one pick per match—the one we believe offers the best chance of landing. And for this clash, Nashville -1 to Win is the tip that rises above the rest. This isn’t just about vibes—it’s supported by strong evidence and statistical consistency that you can’t ignore.

---

Why This Bet is Worth Backing

Nashville are a different animal at home. They’ve secured victories in four of their last five at GEODIS Park and have conceded just one goal or fewer in seven of their last eight home matches. Their defensive discipline is coupled with attacking fluidity, with players like Mukhtar and Surridge finding form at the perfect time. Even without the likes of Boyd and Brugman, they look structured and confident on home turf.

New York City, on the other hand, have been hopeless away from home. One solitary victory on the road this season, combined with two wins in their last 19 MLS away matches, paints a bleak picture. Their form against top-half Eastern Conference teams has been decent—but crucially, those results came mostly at home. Conceding three goals to Houston, who aren’t exactly feared going forward, reveals cracks in a defence that had previously seemed improved.

And let’s not forget the head-to-head record in Tennessee. Nashville have played NYCFC twice at GEODIS Park in MLS and walked away with two wins and zero goals conceded. That’s not a coincidence—it’s a pattern.

As BettingTips4You.com expert Steve Harrington puts it:

“You simply don’t bet against Nashville at home—not when the visitors are a team that crumbles the moment they board a plane. Everything here points to a comfortable win for the hosts.”

---

Expected Correct Score: Nashville SC 2-0 New York City FC

With a solid home defence and NYCFC’s toothless away form, Nashville are likely to shut them out while grabbing a couple of goals themselves. A 2-0 scoreline looks very plausible.

Want to have exclusive tips from experts tipsters delivered right into your inbox? Subscribe Now To Our Newsletter. We will never spam, we fully respect your privacy!

Selected Bookmakers Offers