Everton vs West Ham United Predictions

👇 Choose your bookmaker — tap a logo to claim exclusive sign-up bonuses and free bets.

18+; GambleAware.org; #Ad; Please Bet Responsibly

Everton vs West Ham United predictions for this Premier League fixture. Monday night brings us one of those awkward, slightly uncomfortable reunions that football loves to throw up. On one side, David Moyes sits in the home dugout at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, leading an Everton side who’ve had a bright, if not flawless, start to life in their new ground. On the other, Nuno Espírito Santo takes charge of West Ham for the very first time, having been parachuted in after Graham Potter was shown the door. It’s teacher against pupil in a sense, or perhaps more accurately, former boss against his old employers, with both managers desperate to shift the momentum in their favour. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

Premier League | Sep 29 2025 at 8:00 pm UK at Hill Dickinson Stadium

Everton vs West Ham United Predictions

Could We Be in for a Night of Stalemates at Hill Dickinson?

• Everton’s clean sheet streak: The Toffees have yet to concede at Hill Dickinson Stadium, and they could make it three straight home shutouts in the Premier League.
• West Ham’s first-half struggles: The Hammers have managed only one first-half goal across six games, underlining their tendency to start slowly and cautiously.
• Creative spark missing end product: Jack Grealish has created 13 chances for Everton already, but his teammates’ lack of sharpness has kept the scorelines consistently low.

Best Bet for Everton vs West Ham United

The Toffees’ recent form has been a little bit like biting into a crisp only to find it’s soggy. A few weeks ago, they looked vibrant and efficient with three wins on the bounce, but that spark has fizzled into a three-game stretch without victory. Losing to Liverpool in the Merseyside derby is something the Everton faithful have learned to endure, but crashing out of the EFL Cup against Wolves – a Wolves side who had yet to pick up a single Premier League point – was much harder to stomach. Suddenly, the confident strides have become nervous shuffles.

Yet, Moyes has reason to smile when he looks at his defensive record at their new home. Everton haven’t conceded a single Premier League goal at Hill Dickinson Stadium. Victories over Brighton and a draw with Aston Villa have given them a solid platform, even if their attacking rhythm has stuttered. Another clean sheet on Monday would put them in an exclusive club of teams who managed three consecutive home shutouts in a brand-new stadium. There’s history dangling in front of Moyes, which will no doubt be used as motivation.

West Ham, meanwhile, have been in chaos. Potter’s departure was inevitable after four defeats from their opening five league matches. His last act was a lifeless 2-1 home defeat to Crystal Palace, which ended with boos echoing around the London Stadium. Enter Santo, who has had just days to prepare his team for a clash against a well-drilled Everton. It’s hardly the soft landing one might want. He inherits a squad bruised by results but not devoid of quality. Players like Jarrod Bowen and Lucas Paquetá can cause problems, while Callum Wilson has a history of tormenting Everton. Still, given their fragile confidence and leaky back line – 13 goals conceded already – Santo’s first job is to stop the bleeding before dreaming of swashbuckling football.

This isn’t a glamorous fixture, let’s be honest. It’s more a battle of attrition, a grind between two sides with something to prove and plenty to lose. And when emotions run high like this, matches often tighten up, mistakes get punished, and goals can be scarce.

---

Best Bet for Everton vs West Ham United: Under 1.5 Goals

At BettingTips4You, we take pride in offering one clear prediction per match – no long shopping lists of bets that leave you more confused than a VAR decision. Our philosophy is simple: quality over quantity. We want accountability in what we tip, and we want readers to feel clarity, not chaos. For this particular clash, the standout selection, the bet that towers above the rest, is Under 1.5 Goals.

Why Under 1.5 Goals Makes Sense

If there’s one thing Everton have done well this season, it’s keeping things tight on their own turf. Their defensive setup has been disciplined, almost stubborn, with James Tarkowski and Michael Keane providing the muscle and organisation at the back. Add Jordan Pickford’s steady presence, and suddenly the idea of West Ham breaching this back line more than once feels far-fetched. They’ve gone two Premier League home games without conceding, and let’s not forget they’ve already navigated a tricky Brighton side and a solid Aston Villa outfit in that time.

The stats also back up this expectation of a low-scoring evening. Everton’s recent matches haven’t exactly been thrillers. Their last three fixtures in all competitions have produced just three goals in total, and two of those came against them at Anfield. The 0-0 against Villa underlined a recurring theme: this Everton team are more about graft than glamour.

West Ham arrive with their own baggage. Conceding 13 goals in five league outings screams of a side that’s defensively vulnerable, but Santo’s first task will almost certainly be to shore things up. Managers in his position don’t usually rock up and demand open football; they usually draw the lines deeper, compact the midfield, and ask their players to make it ugly. That’s exactly what’s expected here. The Hammers simply cannot afford another humiliation, so expect them to be cautious.

And even when they do get forward, they’re not exactly flowing with goals. Jarrod Bowen offers spark, Paquetá can create moments, and Callum Wilson is a poacher with history against Everton, but as a unit, West Ham are blunt. They’ve scored just once in the first half across six matches this season. When a team struggles to come alive before the break, it often points towards cagey, low-scoring games.

One shouldn’t forget that both sides are carrying attacking uncertainties. Everton’s reliance on Jack Grealish for creativity is striking – he’s created more chances than almost anyone else in the league, but without the right finishers, those opportunities can die in vain. Beto is still adjusting, Ndiaye is industrious but inconsistent, and Kieran Dewsbury-Hall’s role has been more about energy than end product. This is not an attack brimming with goals.

West Ham face their own selection dilemmas. Tomas Soucek is suspended, robbing them of one of their more consistent presences in midfield. New signing Soungoutou Magassa may slot in, but asking him to dominate against Idrissa Gueye and James Garner is a big ask. Callum Wilson versus Niclas Füllkrug is a toss-up up front, but neither has had much momentum yet this season.

With all of this in mind, it’s no wonder that the most rational view is that goals will be scarce. The game could easily become a tactical deadlock, with Everton’s defensive record clashing against a West Ham side desperate to avoid another defeat.

As Emmanuel Nwankwo, one of our trusted BettingTips4You experts, puts it:
“This isn’t the kind of match where you expect fireworks. Both sides have issues in attack, and Santo’s West Ham will come to contain rather than chase. Under 1.5 goals feels like the safest path here.”

Likely Correct Score

When trying to pin down a correct score, the heart says Everton may sneak it, while the head insists on caution. Considering their clean sheets at home and West Ham’s struggles going forward, a narrow Everton win seems most plausible. A 1-0 victory for the Toffees looks the most reasonable outcome. Everton are hard to break down, and they usually need only one moment of quality – perhaps a Grealish set piece or a scrappy finish from Beto – to edge games like this.

Selected Bookmakers Offers