Everton vs Mansfield Town Predictions

Everton vs Mansfield Town predictions ahead of this Carabao Cup clash. Everton face Mansfield Town at Hill Dickinson Stadium on Wednesday in their first-ever meeting, an EFL Cup second-round clash marking the venue’s cup debut. Read on for our free betting tips and predictions.

EFL Cup | Aug 26 2025 at 7:45 pm UK at Hill Dickinson Stadium

Everton vs Mansfield Town Predictions

Will Mansfield Spoil Everton’s Party at Their New Home?

• Everton’s strong cup starts
  • Last season, Everton began both of their cup campaigns with comfortable wins to nil, showing their intent to take these competitions seriously.
• Mansfield’s attacking form
  • Clough’s side are League One’s joint-top scorers with ten goals, but they have conceded in four of their six matches, highlighting defensive frailties.
• Fortress feel already
  • Everton marked their stadium debut with a 2-0 win over Brighton, ending a long August hoodoo. The mood at Hill Dickinson is now sky-high.

Best Bet for Everton vs Mansfield Town

The Hill Dickinson Stadium has barely caught its breath after hosting its very first competitive match, and now it is about to experience its first taste of cup football. Everton, fresh from their 2-0 Premier League victory over Brighton on Sunday, welcome Mansfield Town in the second round of the EFL Cup. For the Merseyside club, this competition is about more than just advancing; it’s a chance to reward their supporters with a run that could rekindle memories of happier times. For Mansfield, though, this is one of those away nights to savour, a trip to a Premier League side in a brand-new ground that will live long in the memory no matter the outcome.

Mansfield arrive with momentum. Nigel Clough has his side playing with confidence, having turned a rough start into a run of four successive wins across all competitions. The 4-1 thrashing of Leyton Orient at the weekend highlighted their attacking verve, making them joint-top scorers in League One. They will not come to sit back quietly. Still, Everton will feel this is the perfect opportunity to build on their emotional weekend victory and keep the positive vibes flowing in front of a raucous home crowd.

---

Best Bet for this Match

Here at BettingTips4You we believe in clarity, not clutter. Just one prediction per game, the one that stands tallest after all the analysis. For this encounter, our Best Bet is Everton to Win with a -1 Handicap.

Why? Because this is a fixture where the gulf in quality and resources is hard to ignore. Everton may not be blessed with depth — David Moyes has admitted as much — but the players he will field are still of a much higher calibre than those Mansfield can call upon. Jack Grealish stole the headlines on Sunday with two assists, and while he may be rested, the likes of Carlos Alcaraz, Dwight McNeil and Beto are eager to impress. That attacking depth, even with some rotation, should be more than enough to carve open a League One defence.

Mansfield have been excellent going forward, but their back line has not been tested by a Premier League attack. Conceding twice against Doncaster and Burton suggests vulnerabilities, and coming up against James Garner, Iliman Ndiaye (if used), or McNeil running at them is another level entirely. Everton will also want to put on a show for their supporters, who waited so long for this new stadium. Momentum matters, and after finally ending a miserable August run in the league, Moyes will not want to let standards slip.

Our BettingTips4You.com expert Steve Harrington made the point bluntly:

“Mansfield are enjoying their moment, but Everton have too much firepower and too much at stake to take this lightly.”

The Toffees have history in this competition of making strong starts, often winning their early ties comfortably. Mansfield’s spirit may earn them a chance or two, but this feels like a night where the Premier League side will impose themselves from the off. The most likely scoreline? A 3-0 Everton victory — dominant, professional, and another step in turning their new home into a fortress.

Selected Bookmakers Offers