Charlotte FC vs New York City FC Predictions

Charlotte FC vs New York City FC predictions and tips in Major League Soccer. Charlotte FC aim to snap a three-match MLS losing streak as they host New York City FC on Saturday at Bank of America Stadium, chasing a much-needed home win. Read on for our free betting tips and predictions.

MLS Playoffs | Jul 13 2025 at 12:30 am UK at Bank of America Stadium

Charlotte FC vs New York City FC Predictions

Is Home Advantage Enough to Lift Charlotte Past New York City?

• NYCFC’s Away Goal Woes: They’ve failed to score in two of their last three away MLS matches and have just one away win when not trailing at half-time.
• Charlotte Struggle to Hold Leads: Dean Smith’s men have dropped seven points after taking the lead in games this season, including a recent collapse from 2-0 up at home.
• Underwhelming Attacking Returns: Both sides have lacked bite—Charlotte rely heavily on isolated bursts from Agyemang and Biel, while NYCFC are missing their usual creative spark with Freese and Jones unavailable.

Best Bet for Charlotte FC vs New York City FC

Saturday’s MLS showdown at the Bank of America Stadium is more than just another regular season clash—it’s a pivotal moment for two sides with different types of baggage. Charlotte FC are desperate to arrest a poor run that’s seen them go five matches without a win, while New York City FC arrive in North Carolina chasing more consistency, having bounced between wins and defeats like a yo-yo in recent weeks. While neither side is exactly flying, the tension will be high, and both managers know that three points here could drastically reshape their seasons.

Dean Smith’s Charlotte come into this one bruised but not broken. A 2-2 draw at home to Orlando City may look alright on paper, but anyone who watched it will know it felt like a loss. Going 2-0 up in front of your own fans only to toss it all away in the second half isn’t just a poor result—it’s demoralising. Defensive lapses have become a familiar script, with the side now conceding multiple goals in three straight home games. Not exactly the kind of record you want heading into a must-win fixture.

New York City FC, meanwhile, seem incapable of stringing two positive performances together. One week they’re solid, the next they’re anonymous. Their most recent 3-1 win over Toronto might look convincing, but away from home they’ve been timid. Failing to score in two of their last three on the road and winning just once from seven occasions where they were tied or ahead tells a story of a team that struggles to close the deal away from Yankee Stadium.

Best Bet for Charlotte vs New York City FC: Under 2.5 Goals

At BettingTips4You.com, we don’t believe in overwhelming you with endless suggestions. Instead, we dig deep and offer one Best Bet—the tip we believe offers the best value and clarity for your betting strategy. In this case, it’s Under 2.5 Goals, and here’s why.

Firstly, neither of these teams are exactly setting the world alight in the final third. Charlotte do have flashes of attacking life—Pep Biel, Vargas and Agyemang can all produce—but the team lacks consistent build-up play. Even in the 2-2 draw last week, their attacks came more from moments of individual flair than sustained pressure.

New York City have scored just once in their last three away MLS matches. Their away form suggests an inherent lack of confidence when they leave the safety of home. With Matt Freese missing and injuries continuing to pile up—plus the likes of Tayvon Gray and Malachi Jones also absent—the squad looks patchy and thin.

Dean Smith will want a solid response after last week’s collapse, and that could mean Charlotte go more conservative in their approach. Add in the fact that NYCFC have rarely found the net in the first half of away matches, and this sets up for a cautious, tight affair.

“This is one of those matches where the fear of losing might outweigh the will to win. Both sides look vulnerable, and neither are likely to go gung-ho. That’s why Under 2.5 Goals is the logical call.”
– BettingTips4You.com expert Graham Hartshorn

Expect both teams to trade blows cautiously, and while either side might sneak a winner, the margins are likely to be razor-thin. A 1-0 win for Charlotte FC looks just about right, especially with their strong home record against this opponent.

Selected Bookmakers Offers