Bolton Wanderers vs Rotherham United Predictions

Bolton Wanderers vs Rotherham United predictions for this EFL Trophy. Bolton Wanderers face Rotherham United on Tuesday night in EFL Trophy Northern Group E, with both sides seeking to end winless streaks and gain vital group-stage points. Read on for our free match preview and betting tips.

EFL Trophy | Sep 2 2025 at 7:00 pm UK at Toughsheet Community Stadium

Bolton Wanderers vs Rotherham United Predictions

Can Bolton Finally Break Their Draw Streak Against Struggling Rotherham?

• Goals keep flowing
  • Bolton’s last five fixtures have all ended with both teams finding the net, underlining their tendency to score but rarely shut out opponents.
• Rotherham’s defensive problems
  • The Millers have shipped goals in every outing since their opening-day win, showing a worrying inability to keep things tight at the back.
• Burstow the bright spark
  • Mason Burstow has already notched three goals in seven appearances, providing Bolton with much-needed cutting edge during an otherwise frustrating start.

Best Bet for Bolton Wanderers vs Rotherham United

Tuesday night in Northern Group E of the EFL Trophy brings together two sides desperate for relief. Bolton Wanderers have been caught in an endless cycle of stalemates, their season beginning with far too much frustration and not nearly enough satisfaction. Five consecutive draws have tested the patience of their supporters, who must feel like they’re reliving the same match over and over again. For Rotherham United, the story is equally bleak, if not worse. One opening-day win in League One has been followed by six matches without victory inside 90 minutes, a slide that has put their interim boss under pressure before autumn has even arrived.

There’s an air of restlessness around this encounter, as both clubs see the EFL Trophy as a chance to spark life into otherwise stuttering campaigns. Bolton’s fans will argue that they should be higher in the table, especially with the likes of Mason Burstow already providing some much-needed goals. On the other side, Rotherham are clinging to faint hope that Jordan Hugill and Martin Sherif can finally break their attacking slump. The mood going into this fixture is one of necessity rather than luxury—neither side can really afford to shrug it off.

---

Best Bet for this match

Here at BettingTips4You, we believe in offering a single, carefully chosen prediction rather than throwing multiple half-hearted options at readers. This way, you know exactly what we stand behind, and you won’t be left trying to sift through a clutter of conflicting tips. For Bolton Wanderers v Rotherham United, the standout selection, and indeed the Best Bet, is Bolton Wanderers to win and both teams to score.

This may sound brave, considering Bolton have spent more time drawing than winning, but the reasoning is solid. The Trotters have shown they can find the net consistently, with Burstow’s three goals in seven appearances giving their attack some teeth. Their issue has not been scoring, but rather seeing matches through, with four 1-1 draws telling their story. Against a Rotherham defence that has looked brittle, Bolton should be able to exploit weaknesses. The Millers have conceded in every single match since the opening weekend, and even with a back line of Zak Jules, Denzel Hall and Reece James, they have rarely looked steady.

Rotherham are not toothless, though. Hugill and Sherif may not be frightening the division just yet, but Bolton themselves have conceded in each of their last five matches. It’s hard to trust them to keep a clean sheet at this point, especially with their midfield sometimes losing control late in games. That’s where the “both teams to score” element gains real value, as it acknowledges Bolton’s defensive uncertainty while still banking on their greater firepower to see them over the line.

As Emmanuel Nwankwo from BettingTips4You.com put it:

“Bolton’s draw streak tells us they’re competitive but flawed. Rotherham’s struggles, however, make this the perfect chance for Wanderers to edge it—with both nets being rattled along the way.”

When all is considered, Bolton at home, with Burstow leading the line and Morley, Cozier-Duberry and Cissoko buzzing behind him, simply look more likely to take advantage. Rotherham’s reliance on Hugill and Sherif feels like a gamble, and with Sam Nombe sidelined, the visitors lack a reliable cutting edge. Bolton to win with both teams scoring balances the clear evidence of goals with the reality of their shaky defence.

A 2-1 victory for Bolton seems the likeliest scoreline. The hosts are due a break from their endless cycle of draws, while Rotherham’s vulnerabilities should eventually be punished, though not without them nicking a goal.

Selected Bookmakers Offers