Barnsley vs Mansfield Town Predictions

Barnsley vs Mansfield Town Predictions for this League One fixture. Barnsley and Mansfield Town kick off their League One campaigns on Friday evening at Oakwell. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

League One | Aug 9, 2024 at 8pm UK at Oakwell Stadium

Barnsley vs Mansfield Town Predictions

[wptb id=419301]

Will Barnsley’s Quality Overcome Mansfield’s Resilience in League One Opener?

As Barnsley and Mansfield Town gear up for their League One season opener at Oakwell, both sides bring their own narratives and expectations into this clash. Barnsley, eager to rebound from last season’s disappointment of missing out on promotion, face a Mansfield side focused on survival after securing automatic promotion from League Two. This analysis will delve into the key aspects of both teams, their strategies, potential gameplay, and critical predictions for this encounter.

Barnsley’s New Chapter Under Darrell Clarke

Barnsley’s decision to replace Neill Collins with Darrell Clarke late last season did not yield the immediate success the club’s hierarchy had hoped for, as they fell short in the playoff semi-finals. Clarke, despite his mixed results with Cheltenham Town, brings a wealth of experience in guiding teams to promotion. Barnsley’s pre-season has been a mixed bag, capped by a 4-0 defeat to Roma, highlighting the need for tactical refinements before the league begins.

Key additions for Barnsley include defender Marc Roberts from Birmingham City and midfielder Conor Hourihane from Derby County, both returning to familiar surroundings. Clarke’s probable starting lineup includes goalkeeper Jackson Smith, Roberts, and Hourihane, with Tottenham Hotspur loanee Matthew Craig expected to feature. The Tykes’ reliance on these new signings to hit the ground running will be crucial in their bid to start the season on a positive note.

Mansfield Town’s Return to League One

After over two decades away from League One, Mansfield Town’s return is marked by cautious optimism. Under Nigel Clough, the team clinched the final automatic promotion spot in League Two last season. The signings of Australian international Keanu Baccus and seasoned forward Lee Gregory signify their intent to stay competitive at this level.

Mansfield’s pre-season was largely successful, highlighted by a notable 1-0 victory over Oxford United. Clough’s expected lineup features new signing Deji Oshilaja in defence, alongside Frazer Blake-Tracy, with Gregory likely to start from the bench. The Stags’ ability to adapt to the rigours of League One will be put to the test immediately against Barnsley.

Expected Lineups and Tactical Approaches

Barnsley Possible Starting XI:

• Goalkeeper: Jackson Smith
• Defenders: De Gevigney, Roberts, Earl
• Midfielders: O’Keeffe, Connell, Hourihane, Phillips, Styles
• Forwards: Watters, Cosgrove

Barnsley’s setup under Clarke is expected to be dynamic, with a blend of defensive solidity provided by Roberts and the midfield creativity of Hourihane. The wings will be critical, with O’Keeffe and Styles expected to deliver crosses to Watters and Cosgrove up front.

Mansfield Town Possible Starting XI:

• Goalkeeper: Pym
• Defenders: Bowery, Flint, Oshilaja, Blake-Tracy
• Midfielders: Baccus, Reed, S. Quinn, Boateng
• Forwards: Nichols, Akins

Mansfield’s formation is likely to focus on a solid defensive structure with quick transitions through midfield. Baccus and Reed will be pivotal in linking defence with attack, while Akins and Nichols look to exploit any spaces left by Barnsley’s advancing full-backs.

Key Areas and Player Duels

The midfield battle will be a critical area where this match could be decided. Barnsley’s Conor Hourihane, known for his passing range and vision, will face off against Mansfield’s Louis Reed, whose ability to break up play and launch counter-attacks will be crucial. This duel could dictate the tempo of the game and determine which team controls the midfield.

In defence, Barnsley’s Marc Roberts will be tasked with containing Mansfield’s Lucas Akins. Roberts’ experience and aerial ability will be vital in neutralising the threat posed by Akins, who is adept at holding up the ball and bringing others into play.

Gameplay Predictions

Barnsley are likely to dominate possession, leveraging their midfield strength to create scoring opportunities. Clarke’s side will aim to press high and utilise their wing-backs to stretch Mansfield’s defence. Mansfield, on the other hand, will likely adopt a counter-attacking approach, sitting deeper and looking to exploit any gaps left by Barnsley’s advancing players.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Barnsley

Strengths:

• Experience in Key Areas: The additions of Roberts and Hourihane provide a blend of experience and quality.
• Midfield Creativity: Hourihane and Connell offer creativity and passing options.

Weaknesses:

• Defensive Stability: The pre-season defeat to Roma highlights potential vulnerabilities in defence.
• Managerial Uncertainty: Clarke’s recent track record raises questions about his tactical adaptability.

Mansfield Town

Strengths:

• Defensive Organisation: The addition of Oshilaja alongside Flint provides a robust defensive pairing.
• Counter-Attacking Potential: The pace and directness of their forward players can trouble Barnsley’s defence.

Weaknesses:

• Step Up in Competition: The transition from League Two to League One is significant, and Mansfield’s squad depth will be tested.
• Reliance on New Signings: Integrating new players like Baccus and Gregory quickly will be crucial for their survival hopes.

Managerial Analysis

Darrell Clarke has a reputation for achieving promotions with various teams. However, his recent stint with Cheltenham Town was less than impressive, raising questions about his suitability for Barnsley’s ambitions. Clarke’s tactical flexibility will be under scrutiny, especially in his ability to manage games against teams that sit deep and counter-attack.

Nigel Clough, on the other hand, brings stability and experience to Mansfield. His ability to get the best out of a squad often considered underdogs will be essential. Clough’s pragmatic approach could serve Mansfield well, although his team’s lack of experience at this level might pose challenges.

Criticisms of Barnsley

Barnsley’s decision to appoint Darrell Clarke as head coach, despite his mixed track record, is a gamble that may not pay off. Clarke’s stint at Cheltenham Town was marked by inconsistency, and his tactical decisions often left much to be desired. His appointment seems more like a desperate move rather than a strategic decision.

Barnsley’s defence, although reinforced with the signing of Marc Roberts, remains suspect, as evidenced by their heavy defeat to Roma. If Clarke fails to address these defensive issues quickly, Barnsley could find themselves struggling against teams who exploit their vulnerabilities on the counter.

Expected Goals Analysis

Barnsley’s previous season in League One saw them average 1.8 goals per game, indicating a potent attack. However, their defensive record, conceding 1.4 goals per game, suggests a tendency to be involved in high-scoring matches. Mansfield, meanwhile, averaged 2 goals per game in League Two, showcasing their offensive capabilities. Defensively, they conceded 1 goal per game, a respectable figure but one that might be tested more rigorously in League One.

Betting Angles and Trends

Barnsley’s last nine League One matches have seen both teams score, a trend that could continue given Mansfield’s offensive potential. The Tykes’ propensity to find the net, coupled with their defensive frailties, makes the “both teams to score” market particularly appealing. Mansfield’s pre-season form, coupled with their attacking reinforcements, suggests they can contribute to a high-scoring affair.

Predictions

Best Bet: Barnsley to Win and Both Teams to Score Barnsley’s attacking prowess, combined with their defensive vulnerabilities, suggests a match where both sides will find the net. Mansfield, with their confidence buoyed by promotion and pre-season form, are likely to score, but Barnsley’s quality should see them edge out a victory.

Correct Score Prediction: Barnsley 3-1 Mansfield Town Given Barnsley’s attacking statistics and Mansfield’s tendency to concede, a 3-1 scoreline reflects the likelihood of a high-scoring game with Barnsley’s superior quality proving decisive.

Goalscorer Prediction: Max Watters to Score Anytime Watters, expected to lead Barnsley’s attack, has the ability to exploit Mansfield’s defence. His positioning and finishing make him a prime candidate to find the back of the net.

Corner Prediction: Total Corners Over 10.5 Both teams average a high number of corners per game – Barnsley at 5.1 and Mansfield at 6.2. This suggests a game with plenty of attacking play and set-piece opportunities, likely resulting in over 10.5 corners.

Innovative Market: Player Total Shots on Target – Conor Hourihane Over 1.5 Hourihane’s role in midfield sees him frequently involved in attacking play, with his ability to take shots from distance. Expect him to register more than 1.5 shots on target during the match.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter For Exclusive Tips

Want to have exclusive tips from experts tipsters delivered right into your inbox? Subscribe Now To Our Newsletter. We will never spam, we fully respect your privacy!