Plymouth Argyle vs Sheffield United Predictions

Plymouth Argyle vs Sheffield United predictions for this Championship fixture. Plymouth Argyle host high-flying Sheffield United at Home Park, with both sides chasing crucial points at opposite ends of the Championship table in the season’s run-in. Read on for all our free predictions and betting tips.

Championship | Apr 12, 2025 at 12:30pm UK at Home Park

Plymouth Argyle vs Sheffield United Predictions

Could Plymouth Blow the Promotion Race Wide Open?

• Plymouth Finding Home Comforts
  • Despite their league position, the Pilgrims have lost just five of their last 19 home games across all competitions and scored in most of them.
• Blades Still Potent on the Road
  • Sheffield United have found the net in 13 of their last 14 away league fixtures, even during a dip in form.
• Two Sides with Huge Motivation
  • Plymouth are five points from safety and must go for it, while the Blades must win to stay in the automatic promotion fight — both sides are under pressure to attack.

Best Bet for Plymouth Argyle vs Sheffield United

With just a handful of fixtures remaining in this year’s Championship campaign, Home Park plays host to a clash that carries huge weight at both ends of the table. Plymouth Argyle, clinging to survival by the thinnest of threads, are desperately trying to stay afloat in their fight against relegation, while Sheffield United arrive with pressure mounting in the other direction, having slipped out of the top two after back-to-back defeats. This isn’t just a late-season clash — it’s potentially season-defining for both.

Plymouth’s plight is well documented. A season that’s never really clicked has left them stranded at the bottom with just five matches to rescue themselves. They’ve shipped a ridiculous 81 goals — the worst in the division — and their midweek trip to Swansea was nothing short of catastrophic, with the game essentially over before half-time. However, back at Home Park, things haven’t been quite so grim. A spirited win over Norwich and a battling draw with Watford showed there’s still some fire left in Muslic’s team, particularly in front of their own fans. With their fate dangling by a thread, they must summon every last ounce of belief to get something from this one.

The Blades, meanwhile, have gone from looking like nailed-on automatic promotion candidates to suddenly glancing nervously over their shoulders. From sitting top after beating Coventry, they’ve fallen to third after toothless defeats to Oxford and Millwall. Neither loss came with much in the way of positives. Their attacking threat has dulled, and they’ve now failed to score in two straight matches. It’s clear that fatigue, pressure, or perhaps a combination of both, is beginning to show. A third straight loss would be a disaster, and Chris Wilder knows it.

Best Bet for Plymouth vs Sheffield United: Both Teams to Score

At BettingTips4You.com, we keep things straightforward by focusing on just one carefully selected prediction per match – not a shopping list of guesses. For this match, the standout choice is Both Teams to Score, and there are solid reasons to believe this is where the value lies.

First, let’s talk about the home side. Plymouth might be bottom, and yes, their defence has resembled a sieve at times, but they’ve been much more competitive at Home Park. In fact, they’ve lost just five of their last 19 matches there in all competitions, and among the highlights are wins over solid sides like Norwich, Sunderland and Millwall. More importantly, they’ve found ways to score. Ryan Hardie remains their most consistent threat, and they’ve managed to net in each of their last three matches on home soil.

Sheffield United, for all their recent wobble, are still packed with attacking options. Tyrese Campbell leads their scoring charts, and there’s an array of creative talent in midfield capable of unlocking a shaky Plymouth backline. Despite not scoring in their last two, they had found the net in 13 of their previous 14 away matches — a statistic that cannot be ignored. They simply don’t keep clean sheets either, and when you throw in the urgency on both sides, this feels like a game where defences will take a back seat.

As BettingTips4You.com expert Gram Dodd put it:
“With so much riding on this game at both ends of the Championship, there’s no room for caution. Expect goals — from both sides.”

This isn’t a contest either side will approach conservatively. Plymouth need to win, while the Blades can’t afford another slip. It’s a recipe for a frantic, open match.

Predicted Score: Plymouth Argyle 2-2 Sheffield United
Plymouth’s desperation and Sheffield United’s recent shakiness could collide in a contest full of mistakes and openings. A score draw would be dramatic — and plausible — in this context.

---

Want to have exclusive tips from experts tipsters delivered right into your inbox? Subscribe Now To Our Newsletter. We will never spam, we fully respect your privacy!

Selected Bookmakers Offers