bet365
BetMGM
William Hill
Betfred
BetUK
LiveScoreBet
10Bet
Virgin Bet
The dust has barely settled after Brendan Rodgers’ resignation, yet the debate over Celtic’s next step is already frenzied. Bookmakers have lurched from one favourite to another within hours, with Ange Postecoglou’s name pushed forward on sentiment and a familiar smile. Strip out the romance and look at the data, and a different picture emerges. Kieran McKenna offers modern coaching detail, in-game adaptability, and a pragmatic blueprint that suits where Celtic are now — eight points behind Hearts after a 3-1 defeat and with defensive organisation visibly fraying. If we are talking process over nostalgia, system over soundbite, McKenna is the sharp bet at 9/1.
Get Premium Tips before kick-off
Next Permanent Celtic Manager Predictions
Celtic Must Resist the Ange Reunion: Why Kieran McKenna Is the Tactical Revolution the Bhoys Desperately Need at 9/1
- Celtic need a progressive manager who can fix the structure and the standards; Kieran McKenna has the methods and the temperament.
- Ange Postecoglou’s return is more nostalgia than solution; recent evidence points to tactical rigidity and defensive frailty.
- The market noise is chaotic, but the value case is clear: back McKenna at 9/1.
▾
Process over nostalgia: McKenna’s adaptable structure, rest-defence clarity and in-game tweaks address Celtic’s leaks, while Postecoglou’s recent spells exposed rigidity and transition space. Market swings reflect sentiment, not fit. Board priorities favour control and European resilience. Price underrates probability; at 9/1, the upside versus risk makes McKenna the value play.
Context: The Situation Celtic Are Walking Into
Celtic are adrift in the title race at an early stage, their loss at Hearts exposing tactical hesitation and a soft centre. Rodgers’ departure came with a blistering rebuke from major shareholder Dermot Desmond, who accused the former manager of “divisive, misleading and self-serving” behaviour. Regardless of where you sit on that statement, it underlines the need for a calmer, clearer football project. Martin O’Neill, alongside Shaun Maloney, are holding the reins for now, with Falkirk coming up at Celtic Park. The interim choice suggests a desire to steady the ship before a decisive appointment.
Meanwhile, the market has zig-zagged. Postecoglou opened short, tightened to evens at one point, then drifted again. McKenna shifted from 16/1 into single figures, then into much shorter favouritism in places. That volatility screams two things: bookmakers are pricing the narrative, and punters are chasing momentum. Our angle is different — price the fit.
William Hill
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
BetMGM
Bet £10 Get £40 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
bet365
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Betfred
Bet £10 Get £30 In Free Bets
Show Terms & Conditions
10bet
100% Up To £50 On First Deposit
Show Terms & Conditions
The Core Football Argument: Why McKenna Fits Celtic’s Problems
Possession vs Penetration: Matching Game Model to Squad Reality
Celtic’s average possession sits at a lofty 72 per cent, with only Rangers comparable domestically (65). More of the ball is not the issue; what Celtic require is control when they do not have it — rest-defence shape, pressing triggers that suit the opponent, and counter-press structures that prevent transitions. McKenna’s calling card at Ipswich has been the ability to teach layered automatisms quickly: clean spacing between the lines, repeatable build-up patterns, and frequent between-match tweaks to exploit specific weaknesses. That is precisely what Celtic lacked late in Rodgers’ tenure: a reliable way to change the picture mid-game.
In-Game Adjustments: The Difference Between a Plan and a Plan B
Rodgers’ exit was hastened by a perception that he could not flip the script during matches. Postecoglou, both at Tottenham and Nottingham Forest, drew similar criticism. His football, when it sings, is intoxicating. When it falters, the lack of variation is glaring. Forest under Postecoglou averaged 54 per cent possession, then conceded 18 goals across eight very manageable fixtures, including losses to Swansea, Sunderland and Midtjylland. That is not just bad variance; that screams tactical stubbornness and poor rest-defence. With Celtic’s defence giving up five in two against Dundee and Hearts, what is the logic in appointing a coach whose recent setups bleed space between full-backs and centre-halves and ask the midfield to cover impossible distances?
McKenna’s documented strength is game management: shape shifts, rotational tweaks, pinning full-backs with wide triangles, and sensible protection behind the ball. That combination is what Celtic’s current scenario demands.
European Reality Check
The new manager will not only be tasked with chasing Hearts. There is a continental layer: four points from three Europa League matches and the need to climb above a side led by Robbie Keane. Postecoglou’s European record with Celtic — three wins in fourteen main-tournament games, thirty-five goals conceded — is not compatible with a club that must secure rankings points and restore credibility on Thursdays. Ange-ball can overwhelm lesser domestic opposition; it has, however, repeatedly unravelled at European tempo. McKenna’s approach is built on structure first, then incision — a profile that travels better across competitions.
Why Ange Postecoglou Is the Wrong Answer (Right Man, Wrong Moment)
Let us be blunt. Returning to Postecoglou now is a choice driven by sentimentality, not suitability. His recent 39-day failure at Nottingham Forest is not a mere footnote. Six defeats, no wins in eight, and chaotic defending amplify old weaknesses that were visible at Tottenham, where his side shipped sixty-five league goals. The ball dominance at Forest did not deliver control; it delivered exposure. Celtic already own the ball in Scotland. What they need is a manager who can compress space, coordinate counter-presses, and reduce the number of running races towards their own goal.
The argument that Postecoglou “just needs his own players” should alarm supporters. Backing will be debated, budgets will be finite, and immediate improvement is mandatory. A system that takes months to bed in and demands profile-perfect recruitment is misaligned with an urgent title chase. “Never go back” is a cliché for a reason — and Celtic have just lived the comeback story with Rodgers, only to be burned. Rolling those dice again, with a coach whose Plan A is brave but brittle, risks repeating the cycle.
The Alternatives in the Frame — and Why They Fall Short
There are credible names in the market. Wilfried Nancy’s transition-first 3-4-3 is clever, robust, and could punish Scottish defences by overloading the flanks. Robbie Keane is quietly stacking European wins with Ferencváros. Martin O’Neill would almost certainly stabilise things in the short term, and Shaun Maloney brings emotional connection and tactical curiosity. But the job specification today is unusually specific: fix the defensive spacing quickly, maintain high-possession patterns, and restore tactical elasticity. McKenna ticks those boxes with room to spare and, crucially, without demanding wholesale personnel turnover.
Market Movements and Value: Reading the Noise
We have seen McKenna hit a sharp glide path from the long teens (16/1) towards tight single figures, and even odds-on in places later on. Postecoglou has at times been installed favourite, has tightened, and then drifted. Those swings are instructive. They suggest bookmakers reacting to headlines, boardroom gossip and sentiment from supporters who remember a trophy-laden spell. Price is about probability versus suitability. The 9/1 on McKenna is the edge: the number understates his compatibility and overstates the nostalgia tax on Postecoglou.
Tactical Lens: What McKenna Would Change on Day One
Defensive Rest-Shape
Expect a more conservative rest-defence with full-backs staggered rather than mirrored, a single pivot screening lanes rather than chasing shadows, and a centre-back pair instructed to defend forwards rather than dropping off ten yards. The aim is simple: reduce transition threat without ceding territorial control.
Possession to Penetration
Celtic will still dominate the ball, but the possession will be purpose-built. McKenna typically encourages third-man combinations and overloads wide channels to pull blocks apart, then uses late runners to attack the gap. It is repeatable football, not freedom with faith.
Match-Phase Coaching
McKenna is comfortable flipping from a 2-3-5 to a 3-2-5 in build-up, then closing with a 4-4-2 out-of-possession block to see out leads. That versatility is exactly what Rodgers’ Celtic lacked and what Postecoglou historically resists.
Historical Context: Why This Choice Shapes the Next Two Seasons
Celtic cannot afford another misstep after Rodgers’ abrupt exit and the public criticism from the club’s biggest individual shareholder. They are eight points back already. In Europe, they are behind Robbie Keane’s side in the standings. This is not a moment for indulgence or reunion tours. It is a moment to pick a coach who can make marginal gains feel like leaps: stabilise the back line, sharpen the press, add clarity in possession, and bank points quickly. McKenna has shown he can drag clubs upwards by design, not merely by vibes.
Our Take
Appoint Kieran McKenna. Do it before hesitation hands the initiative to others. The Postecoglou option is a mirror held up to the past and to an idea that dazzles when everything aligns but collapses under pressure. Forest conceded eighteen goals in eight winnable matches with him, and Tottenham conceded sixty-five in a Premier League season — numbers that expose a stubborn commitment to high-risk spacing without the rest-defence to support it. Meanwhile, Celtic’s current reality is a defence that has coughed up five across two games and a league gap that will widen if transitions remain unchecked.
McKenna is not just a “fresh face”; he is a coach with a coherent training methodology, repeatable solutions, and the willingness to adjust on the touchline rather than sermonise after the fact. His odds shortened for good reason: decision-makers rate his ceiling and his processes. If you can still find 9/1, it is a price that underrates fit and overweights familiarity with Postecoglou. Football should not be guided by sentiment or by the bookmaker carousel. It should be guided by the alignment between a team’s needs and a manager’s tools. On that measure, McKenna is the clear pick.
Prediction and Suggested Bet
Celtic’s board will prioritise a coach who can repair defensive shape quickly while protecting a high-possession identity and offering European resilience. That profile points squarely at Kieran McKenna. Back Kieran McKenna to be the next Celtic manager at 9/1. The rationale is straightforward: the tactical fit is superior, the recent performance markers support a fresh appointment, and the market noise around Postecoglou is driven by nostalgia rather than football logic.
Enhance your betting game with our daily free betting tips, predictions, and accumulators.
Don’t forget to visit our Free Bets page for the best possible value as well as our Predictions.
Subscribe To Our Newsletter For Exclusive Tips
Want to have exclusive tips from experts tipsters delivered right into your inbox? Subscribe Now To Our Newsletter. We will never spam, we fully respect your privacy!
Selected Bookmakers Offers
| |
New cust. Deposit £10+ in 7 days & bet on sports. Min odds apply. Reward = 4 x £10 Free Bets (2 x £10 Bet Builders & 2 x £10 Sports bet). Valid 7 days. Free bets not valid on e-sports & non UK/IE horse racing. 18+. T&Cs apply. | |
| |
Open Account Offer - New Customers only. Bet £10 and get £30 in Free Bets when you join bet365. Sign up, deposit between £5 and £10 to your account and bet365 will give you three times that value in Free Bets when you place qualifying bets to the same value settle. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits. Min odds/bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. T&Cs , time limits & exclusions apply. Registration Required. #Ad. 18+ Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
18+. Play Safe. From 00:01 on 18.10.2022. £30 bonus. New customers only. Minimum £10 stake on odds of 1/2 (1.5) or greater on sportsbook (excluding Virtual markets). Further terms apply. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New customers only. Register, deposit with Debit Card, and place first bet £10+ at Evens (2.0)+ on Sports within 7 days to get 3 x £10 in Sports Free Bets & 2 x £10 in Acca Free Bets within 10 hours of settlement. 7-day expiry. Eligibility exclusions & T&Cs Apply. | |
| |
New cust only. Opt-in required. Deposit & place a bet within 7 days and settle a £10 minimum bet at odds of 4/5 (1.8) or greater to be credited with 3 x £10 Free Bets: 1 x £10 horse racing, 1 x £10 Free Bet Builder and 1 x £10 football. Free Bets cannot be used on e-sports and non-UK/IE horse racing. 7 day expiry. Stake not returned. 18+. T&Cs apply. Acca Club: Available to new & existing customers. 3 or more selections. Min Odds: 3/10 (1.3) per leg. Max stake: £500. Max Winnings: £200,000 per boost. Profit Boost amounts vary. Horse Racing, Greyhounds & Trotting excluded. Exclusions apply. Full T&C’s apply. 18+ GambleAware.org. | |
 | |
New members only. £10+ bet on sports (ex. Virtuals) 1.5 min odds, settled within 14 days. Free Bets: accept in 7 days, valid 7 days; £20 use on sportsbook, £10 on Bet Builder. Stake not returned. T&Cs.+ deposit exclusions apply #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New bettors. Select bonus at signup or use code SPORT. Wager deposit & bonus 8x. Max qualifying bet = bonus. Valid 60 days. Odds, bet & payment limits apply. T&Cs Apply; 18+ | Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
New customers only, 18+. Min deposit £10. Place a £50 bet on any sport at 2.0+ to qualify for £25 in free bets and 10 Free Spins. Free Bets and Spins valid 7 days. £0.10 Free Spins. T&Cs apply. Please bet responsibly. #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
| |
New members only. £10 min deposit & bet on sportsbook (ex. virtuals), placed & settled at 1.5 min odds in 14 days of sign-up. Win part of E/W bets. Free Bets: accept in 7 days, valid 7 days, use on sportsbook only (ex. virtuals), stakes not returned. T&Cs Apply and deposit exclusions apply. Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
 | |
18+ New customers only. Opt in, and bet £10 on football markets (odds 2.00+). No cash out. Get 6x£5 football free bets at specified odds for set markets, which expire after 7 days. Offer valid from 12:00 UK Time on 25/08/2023. Card payments only. T&Cs Apply | gambleaware.org | Please gamble responsibly #Ad. 18+Only, gambleaware.org | |
